Today is the 40th anniversary of a Giants 4-1 win over the Dodgers at Candlestick Park. A crowd of 31,169 were treated to Juan Marichal’s eighth win of the season, the leading total in the majors. The victory gave the Dominican Dandy a .693 career winning percentage (138 and 61), a mark that surpassed Whitey Ford’s 690 as the all-time best in the big leagues.
Marichal’s win also gave him a 14 and 0 record against the Giants’ arch rivals in the 17 games the two played at Candlestick since 1961. In the following seasons, the Giants' ace continued to rack up wins against the visiting Dodgers. By the end of the 1971 season, Marichal stood 21 and 1 in this regard.
Here is a research piece I wrote on some of these games. This article is scheduled to appear in SABR’s The National Pastime later this year. I’d like to thank Jim Charlton, SABR’s Publication Editor, for his permission to publish this piece here in advance.
Candlestick Magic: Juan Marichal’s Amazing Home Record Against the Los Angeles Dodgers
By Jay Roberts
Juan Marichal once said, “…if you can walk on one leg, you can play against the Dodgers.”
Play against them he did. In Los Angeles, the Dodgers won a respectable 14 of 30 decisions against the high-kicking righty. 400 miles up the coast, it was another story. From 1961 to 1973, Marichal faced the men in blue caps a total of 31 times on the Giants' windswept turf (30 as a starter plus one relief appearance). Towards the end of his illustrious career, when injuries began to take their toll on his six-foot frame, the Dodgers got the best of the future Hall of Famer. In their last four encounters in San Francisco, Los Angeles defeated Marichal three times.
Before those losses, however, Marichal owned the Giants’ arch-rivals in a way that defies belief. When the native of Laguna Verde, the Dominican Republic, blanked them in May 1971, the 1-0 victory ran his home record against Los Angeles to 21 and 1.
True, Marichal benefited from excellent run support (average of 5.64 runs), home field advantage and having to face Sandy Koufax just two times. But these were, for the most part, very good Dodger teams (.551 winning percentage), fighting perennially with the Giants for the pennant or bragging rights.
Win (21), lose (4), or no decision (6), these 31 contests were a significant component of Juan Marichal’s 16-year career. What follows is a look back at seven select games.
Sunday, August 12, 1962
A Sweet Sweep
“Choke artists,” the reporter said. It was late July and the first place Dodgers had just swept three games from the second place Giants at Dodger Stadium. San Francisco, in the lead when the month started, dropped to four games back.
Skipper Alvin Dark’s ball club responded to the charge, winning ten of their next dozen games. This Sunday afternoon contest, the last of the regular season between the two arch-rivals, was the 11th game of that stretch. Marichal, praised by Joe King in The Sporting News as the team’s new pitching leader, scattered four hits, walked one and struck out eight in a complete game win.
A crowd of 41,812, the largest of the season so far at the Giants’ three-year old home park, watched a 10-hit attack by the orange and black. Marichal got help from fellow countryman Felipe Alou who scored three times and Jose Pagan who drove in three.
“My curve was breaking pretty good today,” the 24-year old righty said after the game.
The 5-1 victory made Marichal 3 and 0 against the Dodgers at Candlestick with two no decisions. More importantly, it pulled them to within two and a half of their first place rivals. The two teams tied at the end of the regular season and played a three-game pennant playoff. Marichal started in Game Three at Dodger Stadium, giving up three runs in seven innings. San Francisco won the game and their first pennant with a four run rally in the top of the ninth.
Sunday, August 22, 1965
Mays’s Three Run Homer Wins Infamous Game
From July 6, 1962 to July 8, 1967, Juan Marichal tallied a winning decision 14 out of 15 times against the Dodgers at Candlestick Park. Had he been able to control his temper on a summer afternoon in 1965, the man who wore number 27 might have made it a perfect 15 for 15. “The date was August 22,” Arnold Hano wrote in his biography of Willie Mays, “and if there has been a more bitter baseball game played in my lifetime, I do not recall it.”
Coming into this contest, the final of a four-game set at “The ‘Stick,” the National League pennant race burned hot in four cities. The Dodgers’ 6-4, 11th inning defeat of the Giants the day before moved Los Angeles past Milwaukee into first place. Herman Frank’s ball club fell to one and a half games out. The fourth place Reds were just one game behind in the loss column.
A crowd of 42,807, the largest of the season so far at Candlestick, settled in to watch a rare match up between Marichal and Sandy Koufax. The two greats had faced each other just three other times.
After Walter Alston’s squad jumped out to a two to one lead, Marichal led off the bottom of the third inning. Believing John Roseboro’s return throw to Sandy Koufax nicked him in the ear, Marichal clubbed the Dodger catcher over the head with his bat. A free-for-all ensued which ended with Marichal getting thrown out of the game.
After play resumed, Koufax struck out Bob Schroder, who was batting for the ejected Marichal. After retiring Tito Fuentes on a fly to left, Koufax then walked Jim Davenport and Willie McCovey. Willie Mays was up next. He connected for his 38th homer of the season to give the Giants a four to two lead.
The Dodgers pulled to within a run in the ninth off Marichal’s replacement, eventual winner Ron Herbel. With the tying run on second, relief specialist Masanori Murakami came on and retired Maury Wills and Jim Gilliam to end the three hour and 18 minute contest.
The tainted victory moved the Giants to within one percentage point of the Dodgers who stayed in first with Milwaukee’s loss to Pittsburgh. San Francisco sputtered in the days following this unforgettable game, but Marichal’s return from a nine-day suspension galvanized their stretch run. San Francisco won 14 in a row in the first half of September but were denied their second pennant when the Dodgers assembled a 13-game pearl necklace and took the flag by two games over the Giants.
Saturday, August 27, 1966
Giants Take the League Lead
In what proved to be the Senior Circuit’s last close pennant race before divisional play began in 1969, the Giants and the Dodgers locked horns again in 1966. The Pittsburgh Pirates joined the fray in June and made it a three team run to the wire.
On the morning of Saturday, August 27, the standings in the newspapers showed the Giants just one-half game behind the first place Pirates, with the Dodgers one and a half back. A near-capacity crowd of 41,876 fans made their way to the stadium just south of San Francisco to see Marichal take on Don Drysdale. The husky fireballer hoped to end his personal five-game losing streak to Marichal at Candlestick.
Willie Davis helped Big Blue’s cause in the sixth with a solo homer off Marichal that gave the Dodgers a two to one lead. Wasting no time in their comeback effort, the Giants struck back in the bottom of the frame. Willie Mays opened with a single off Drysdale. Dodger skipper Walter Alston then ordered the outfield shift for Willie McCovey, who promptly drove in Mays with a double to an empty left field. McCovey then scored on a single off the bat of Jesus Alou. In the bottom of the eighth, Mays added an insurance run with his 33rd homer of the year, career number 538.
Marichal, whose dazzling arsenal of pitches were showcased in a June cover story by Time magazine, allowed just one single after Davis’s circuit shot in the sixth. “I had very good control,” the star ace said afterwards. “I especially was able to get the ball high and outside to those seven left-handed batters in the Dodger lineup.”
Marichal’s 19th win of the season gave him a 13-0 record against the Dodgers at Candlestick and made Drysdale oh for six in this regard. The four to two victory moved the Giants passed the Pirates into first place. In the closing days, San Francisco tried valiantly to grab the pennant, winning their last five games. The race came down to the final day with the Dodgers needing to win one of two in their double-dip in Philadelphia. Los Angeles lost the first game, but Koufax won the second for the team’s second consecutive title.
Thursday, June 27, 1968
The First Loss
Although the subject of trade rumors during the off season, Marichal got off to a great start in 1968. Coming in to this contest, he had won eight in a row for a 14 and 2 record. The informed Giants fan in the Thursday night crowd of 13,566 knew Marichal’s ninth straight win would not only pull the second place Giants to within five and a half of the idle Cardinals, it would also extend his record against the Dodgers at Candlestick to 16 and 0.
In the third inning, with the scored tied at two, Willie McCovey took starter Bill Singer deep for a second time in the contest. Behind 5-2, the Dodgers came back with two in the fifth on a double by Willie Davis and one in the seventh on a solo home run by Lenny Gabrielson.
In the top of the 11th, with the score tied at 5, Zoila Versalles led off the inning against Marichal. The “good-field, no-hit” American League transplant, batting just .168 at the time, managed to get his second homer of the year. “It was up high, just high enough,” the native of Cuba said afterwards.
In the bottom of the 11th, Jack Hiatt singled and rookie Bobby Bonds walked off Don Sutton. Sutton, the fifth Dodger pitcher, had already tossed three scoreless innings in relief. Normally used as a starter, the future Hall of Famer proceeded to do something no Dodger hurler had ever done. He squashed the rally to pin a Candlestick loss on Marichal. (San Francisco, with Marichal as the starter, had lost once before at home to Los Angeles (May 19, 1961), but the losing pitcher was Billy O’Dell.)
Saturday, September 20, 1969
Six-Time 20 Game Winner
With about a dozen games left in the chase for the National League’s first Western Division title, San Francisco clung to a half-game lead over Atlanta. L.A. stood just one and a half paces back coming into this Saturday afternoon contest.
Before the game, Walter Alston, skipper of the Dodgers from 1954 to 1976, held a meeting with his players to discuss the “Candlestick Whammy.” Perhaps he should have dubbed it the “Marichal Whammy.” Los Angeles, from 1960 through the previous night’s game, held a 32 and 59 record in San Francisco. Against Marichal, they were 1 and 17.
“I think that some players have done too much complaining about the weather and the condition of the field – about how hard it is to play here,” Alston said. “We’ve just got to go out and play.”
Seemingly inspired, the Dodgers scored single runs off Marichal in the second and fourth innings. In the bottom of the fourth, Willie McCovey cracked a seeing-eye single off starter Bill Singer. McCovey and Bobby Bonds then scored on a single by Hal Lanier. Willie Mays capped off the five-run outburst with a run-scoring single off reliever Pete Mikkelsen.
Marichal, asked before the game about his overall success at Candlestick Park, replied, “It’s the weather. I like the cool weather here.” After he gave up a two-run homer to Willie Davis in the fifth, Marichal kept the Dodgers’ bats cool until the top of the ninth. With two outs, Ted Sizemore doubled to put the tying run in scoring position. With a national TV audience watching and a crowd of 25,213 biting their nails, Marichal bore down and retired Davis for the final out.
The 5-4 win gave Marichal a sixth season with at least 20 wins. The victory ran his Candlestick record against the Dodgers to 18 and 1 and dropped them to two and a half back. The Giants defeated the Dodgers the next day for a three game sweep that kept them ahead of Atlanta by one half game. With four games left in the season, Marichal beat L.A. 8-1 at Dodger Stadium, a complete game effort that lowered his league leading ERA to 2.10. It wasn’t enough however as San Francisco was denied again. The Braves won 10 of their last 11 to take the flag by three games over the Giants.
Saturday, May 15, 1971
21 and 1
Sandy Koufax, Don Drysdale and Orlando Cepeda were no longer part of the rivalry. Willie Mays was less powerful and Maury Wills less swift. The San Francisco Chronicle and The Los Angeles Times poured less ink into their baseball barrels. Average attendance at Candlestick had dipped below 12,000. But once again, in 1971, the Giants and Dodgers sported solid outfits who fought each other for the chance to play October ball.
Charlie Fox’s Giants charged out of the gate, winning 18 of their first 23 games. By the time Los Angeles arrived in San Francisco for their first meeting of the season in mid-May, San Francisco led their nemesis by eight games.
On Saturday, May 15, Marichal and Bill Singer treated a crowd of 33,370 fans, largest of the season so far at Candlestick, to a pitching duel. The veteran Singer, winless in two Candlestick tries against Marichal, took a no-hitter into the seventh inning. Willie Mays, a week shy of his 40th birthday and batting a hefty .368, broke up the no-no with a ground rule double over the left field fence. He then scored the only run of the game on the Giants only other hit of the day, a one-out single to left by Marichal’s battery-mate Dick Dietz.
Marichal, who never lost to the Dodgers at Candlestick on a Saturday (8-0-1), allowed eight base runners but stranded seven. The six-hit blanking ran his Candlestick record to 21-1 against Los Angeles and gave him 49 career shutouts, the most among active pitchers. After the game, he noted, “… I am happy with the win. Every one is important no matter how many games ahead we are. You never know what can happen.”
Add soothsaying to Marichal’s list of talents. The 1-0 win gave San Francisco a 10-game lead, but the Dodgers stormed back in the second half. Their late-season drive included a 5-4 defeat of Marichal at Candlestick, just the second such victory in 11 years. Needing a win on the final day of the season to prevent a playoff with the Dodgers, the Giants and Marichal beat the Padres to clinch the division pennant.
Sunday, August 5, 1973
Their Final Meeting
In October 1972, Marichal underwent surgery to repair a herniated disc. Recovered, he won the ’73 lid-lifter in Cincinnati for a franchise record sixth Opening Day win. In May, the Dodgers defeated him for just the third time at Candlestick. The 35-year old gave up just one earned run in eight innings and was victimized by third baseman Dave Kingman’s throwing error that let in two unearned runs.
In early July, skipper Charlie Fox demoted a struggling Marichal to spot starter and reliever. But he soon regained his starter status and faced the Dodgers one last time at Candlestick on a Sunday afternoon in early August. The third place Giants were six and a half games back of their first place rivals. Attendance at the now enclosed stadium would not even reach the 1M mark for the season, but this contest drew 33,122, the largest of the season so far at Candlestick.
Marichal, lifted for a pinch hitter in the bottom of the third, gave up four runs, three of which were unearned. Not going down without a fight, the Giants rallied from a 4-1 deficit. With one out in the eighth and Dave Rader on second, Bobby Bonds slugged a home run off starter Tommy John. The shot made him only the fifth player in big league history to hit 30 homers and steal 30 bases in a season. He joined Willie Mays as only the second player to accomplish the feat twice.
In the bottom of the ninth, Chris Speier’s smash line drive off reliever Jim Brewer went through third baseman Ron Cey’s legs. The Giants shortstop raced to third when left fielder Bill Buckner bobbled the ball. Mixing in screwballs with his heater, Brewer retired the next three Giants to end the game.
Marichal was saddled with the loss, just his fourth in 14 years against Los Angeles at Candlestick Park. The Dodgers swept the Giants at Candlestick in mid-September (Marichal did not pitch) to get to within
two games of the Reds, but finished four back. Marichal’s final appearance at Candlestick came against San Diego on Saturday, September 22. He scattered nine hits and picked up his final win in a Giants uniform.
Epilogue
Juan Marichal was inducted into the National Baseball Hall of Fame in 1983. His list of accomplishments include a 243 and 142 record, six 20-win seasons, a no-hitter, an epic, 16-inning win at Candlestick Park and nine All-Star team selections.
A lesser-known achievement is his home record against the Dodgers. The final tally was 21 and 4 with six no decisions. In the 31 games, 18 of which he completed, the Giants were 24 and 7. Of those seven losses, all but two were one-run margins. Marichal’s cumulative ERA was 2.28.
Sources
Periodicals
Los Angeles Times
San Francisco Chronicle
San Francisco Examiner
The Sporting News
Magazines
Time, July 1966
Books
Cruz, Hector J. Juan Marichal: the Story of His Life.
Gillette, Gary and Palmer, Pete. The Baseball Encyclopedia.
Goldblatt, Andrew. The Giants and the Dodgers, Four Cities, Two Teams, One Rivalry.
Mandel, Mike. SF Giants, An Oral History.
Marichal, Juan With Einstein, Charles. A Pitcher's Story.
Special Publications
Juan Marichal Hall of Fame Day. Woodford Associates, San Francisco.
Websites
Baseball-Reference.com
Retrosheet.com
Marichal Versus Dodgers at Candlestick
Note: All are starts except one relief appearance on May 9, 1965
5-19-1961 LA 8, SF 7 ND 0-0-1 7.1 – 4 5.07 31,215 Perranoski W
8-19-1961 SF 5, LA 0 W 1-0-1 5.2 – 0 2.77 29,159 Williams L
9-9-1961 SF 9, LA 6 ND 1-0-2 3.1 – 1 2.80 28,635 Perranoski L
7-6-1962 SF12, LA 3 W 2-0-2 9 – 3 2.87 41,569 Williams L
8-12-1962 SF 5, LA 1 W 3-0-2 9 – 1 2.24 41,812 Williams L
5-24-1963 SF 7, LA 1 W 4-0-2 9 – 1 2.00 40,676 Koufax L
6-19-1963 SF 8, LA 3 W 5-0-2 7.2 – 1 1.87 41,384 Drysdale L
9-7-1963 SF 5, LA 3 W 6-0-2 9 – 2 2.73 36,879 Drysdale L
5-8-1964 SF 3, LA 0 W 7-0-2 9 – 0 1.65 40,547 Ortega L
6-27-1964 SF 9, LA 1 W 8-0-2 9 – 1 1.58 38,810 Moeller L
5-9-1965 SF 6, LA 3 W 9-0-2 1.1 – 0 1.55 40,596 Koufax L
6-28-1965 SF 5, LA 0 W 10-0-2 9 – 0 1.40 36,702 Drysdale L
8-22-1965 SF 4, LA 3 ND 10-0-3 3 – 2 1.55 42,807 Koufax L
5-3-1966 SF 8, LA 1 W 11-0-3 9 – 1 1.50 35,193 Drysdale L
6-12-1966 SF 3, LA 2 W 12-0-3 9 – 2 1.54 42,402 Drysdale L
8-27-1966 SF 4, LA 2 W 13-0-3 9 – 2 1.57 41,876 Drysdale L
5-26-1967 SF 4, LA 1 W 14-0-3 9 – 1 1.53 31,619 Sutton L
7-8-1967 SF 8, LA 4 W 15-0-3 9 – 4 1.69 31,849 Drysdale L
6-27-1968 LA 6, SF 5 L 15-1-3 11 – 6 1.93 13,566 Sutton W
4-30-1969 SF 3, LA 0 W 16-1-3 9 – 0 1.82 14,129 Singer L
7-19-1969 SF 5, LA 4 W 17-1-3 9 – 4 1.94 26,216 McBean L
9-20-1969 SF 5, LA 4 W 18-1-3 9 – 4 2.04 25,213 Singer L
5-27-1970 SF11, LA 3 W 19-1-3 9 – 2 2.04 7,641 Vance L
7-3-1970 LA 8, SF 6 ND 19-1-4 6 – 3 2.12 25,330 Brewer W
9-11-1970 SF 4, LA 3 W 20-1-4 6 – 3 2.19 8,574 Sutton L
5-15-1971 SF 1, LA 0 W 21-1-4 9 – 0 2.10 33,370 Singer L
7-4-1971 LA14, SF 4 ND 21-1-5 7 – 3 2.15 30,663 Mikkelsen W
9-13-1971 LA 5, SF 4 L 21-2-5 4.2 – 4 2.27 31,081 Singer W
7-2-1972 SF 9, LA 3 ND 21-2-6 4.2 – 2 2.30 23,285 Sutton L
5-11-1973 LA 3, SF 2 L 21-3-6 8 – 1 2.27 21,234 Downing W
8-5-1973 LA 4, SF 3 L 21-4-6 3 – 1 2.28 33,122 Johnson W
Recent Comments