The return of the swallows to Capistrano. Bill Veeck’s bat on a ball. Birds and blooms.
They all say springtime, but with less than a month to Opening Day, let’s make it a grand slam with talk of some new baseball books.
One title getting some attention is, “The Summer of '68: The Season That Changed Baseball--and America.” The author is Tim Wendel, a SABR member who lives in Northern Virginia. Haven’t read this one, but it is getting great reviews.
I sometimes wince at titles like that, but you can’t get much more rocky than 1968. I was twelve. The thing is, for me, it’s one of those memory holes. The boob tube as a panacea seems to have worked. I have few memories of all the trouble, and can only recall watching Hawaii Five-O, the Apollo missions and the World Series.
Speaking of looking back at baseball seasons, Jeff Dolman, a self-described “Strat-o-Matic fanatic,” is doing just that. A Red Sox fan living in Culver City, California, he is more of a shape-shifter. At his blog, “1924 And You Are There,” he replayed that season. Simultaneously, he reported the results through Vinny Spanelli and Cal Buttertworth, two fictional characters, and also posted vintage photographs. Dolman also published a book on the season.
His next creative effort looks even better. Seemingly enamored with the Giants, he’s embarked on the 1958 season. The twist this time is what he calls a “Season Long Whowunit.” He writes, "I have no idea how this season and format will play out, but I can guarantee it will be amusing, entertaining, and different."
Hoping Jeff doesn’t mind, here’s a sample of his writing: (Editor note: Don’t read if eating).
Hosing seagull crap and wiping it off a fence with a giant sponge at the end of a long mop was one thing. Getting it off the Seals Stadium scoreboard was another. Milwaukee was pounding Cincy all afternoon, the only out-of-town game everyone was following, but it was hard to see the actual score with dried hunks of white goop all over it. I ended up watching us beat St. Louis again from the grounds crew alley, and the view was awful. When Mays doubled into the left corner off Mizell to set up the winning rally in the 3rd, all I saw was him swing and tear around the first base bag. I guess that’s exciting enough by itself, but the last thing I wanted to do was crane my neck out more and catch a glimpse of Old Forster working my grandstand section and farting it up.
Maybe I should’ve been nicer to Liz on the phone. It’s tough to fake your mood, though. My local team was 6-2, had first place all to themselves, the city was doing somersaults, and I was a puddle of mess.
Another Giants-related book is "The Emerald Diamond: How the Irish Transformed America's Greatest Pastime," by Charlie Rosen. Great to see he covers Connor and McGraw, and the Giants great Irish players.
I do have one criticism, minor but worth clarifying. In writing about Jim Mutrie, the author provides a quote attributed to him, as saying, “My boys are not only giants in statue but in baseball ability.”
The author adds, “That is how, why and when the Gothams officially became the Giants.”
There’s been several versions of this story, so it is confusing. In “The New York Giants,” his once definitive history of the franchise (1952), Frank Graham told us the nickname arose in the summer of 1885 when Mutrie said, “My big fellows! My Giants!” 33 years later, Noel Hynd’s research found a similar Mutrie quote.
Sounded good to all of us, but in the last several years, historians have dug deeper into the origin of the Giants nickname and found better info.
Peter Mancuso sussed all this out in his bio of Mutrie.
The report of this game in one New York newspaper is of particular relevance to a significant piece of baseball history and to part of the Mutrie legend. The game report, which appeared the following day, April 14, in The World, is what gave the New York NL club its permanent nickname "Giants." Although The World's coverage of the game lacks a byline, there is some evidence that the report was written by P. J. Donahue. This game report gives no indication that Mutrie did or said anything to establish the team's new name.
In fact, there has yet to be found any 19th-century account of Mutrie doing or saying anything that resulted in the name "Giants," despite there being scores of 20th-century accounts claiming that he named the team. More than 30 years later, Mutrie would claim that he had coined the nickname in 1888 by referring to his players as "giants" at an exciting moment during a game. Mutrie may well have used the name "Giants" before or after 1888, but regardless, the team's nickname had been immediately popularized and in common use within weeks of the April 14, 1885 story in The World.[37]
Still, this one looks good and right on time for St. Patty’s Day (and damn good title!)
Continuing with the Giants, Roy Kerr, who wrote Roger Connor’s biography last year, will be releasing Buck Ewing: A Baseball Biography this summer. Kerr is also working on a bio of Dan Brouthers, to be titled Big Dan Brouthers: 19th C. Baseball's Slugging King, which should come out late 2013. No Giants connection with Brouthers, but take a look at all the black for him at Baseball Reference, as well as his WAR. What a stud.
We mentioned Bill Veeck at the start, and he too, is in the lineup. In fact, with Paul Dickson as the author, Bill Veeck: Baseball’s Greatest Maverick (Walker) could very well be the clean up hitter.
And finally, a silver anniversary for Bill James’s 1982 Baseball Abstract, a book that began the transformation of the way we see baseball. Chris Jaffe pens an ode to James, who spoke at the MIT Sloan Sports Analytics Conference in Boston earlier this month. Many who were inspired by him will speak and attend tomorrow’s SABR Analytics Conference in Phoenix.
We’ve come along way since 1982, and now sit firmly in a Golden Era of baseball books.
What? “Moneyball” didn’t win the Oscar for Best Movie?
Recent Comments